Food in a heart

Can Food Profiling Provide Better Regulatory Basis than “Ultraprocessed”?

Ultraprocessed foods and their definition have become a common (and contentious) point among the food industry, regulators, and consumer groups, with the HHS proposing a definition that has not been publicly posted and a number of states codifying their own definitions and regulations. In early November, another organization brought an option to the table.

Although not focused directly on ultraprocessed foods, but with essentially the same purpose, the World Health Organization (WHO) published a draft consultation on “Integrated food profiling model for regulatory measures.” With the purpose of addressing and preventing diet-related non-communicable diseases and focusing on identifying industrially produced foods that should be consumed in moderation, the WHO proposed combining:

  • Nutrients of public health concern, including free sugars, sodium, saturated fats and trans fats, with
  • Ingredients used primarily for sensory purposes to increase foods’ appeal: flavors, colors, sweeteners

to identify foods that warrant moderate consumption.

The recommendation is not intended to determine whether a food is healthy or unhealthy, to classify foods according to processing, nor to imply that flavors, colors and sweeteners  are unsafe. Nor does it mean to indicate that a food not included in this profile is necessarily healthy. Instead, it is intended to help identify products that should be consumed in moderation and provide a basis upon which regulators can develop guidance and/or regulation.

While the food profiling approach has some overlap with the Nova classification of ultraprocessed foods (Group 4) – identifying about 97% of the same foods; the two have differing purposes. That is, while Nova Group 4 classifies foods and drinks based on the extent, nature, and purpose of processing (how and why a product was made), the WHO food profiling categorizes foods based on their nutritional composition and health impact (what is in the food) and includes foods that are formulated primarily to increase appeal and consumption. It is the Nova system on which the definitions and regulations in the U.S. tend to be more closely based.

As discussed in the WHO document, the core principle of a healthy diet is moderation, with the specific composition varying by individual needs, culture, and availability of foods. In that context, the WHO recommendations for saturated fatty acids and trans-fatty acids, sugars, and sodium apply to total dietary intake, not just individual foods. Thus, while foods that have higher dietary risk should be limited, all “ultraprocessed” foods should not be considered the same. Thus, in setting regulations, the WHO recommends that regulators consider general policies that include marketing protection for children, front-of-pack labeling, public food procurement and service policies, taxation of sugar-sweetened beverages, food/beverage reformulation policies, and healthy diet behavior change communication and mass-media interventions.

The WHO’s specific dietary recommendations, based on overall dietary intake, include:

  • Total fat: adults limit intake to 30% of total energy intake or less.
  • Saturated fatty acids: adults and children reduce intake to 10% or less of total energy intake.
  • Trans-fatty acids: adults and children reduce intake to 1% or less of total energy intake.
  • Free sugars: adults and children reduce intake to 5% to 10% of total energy intake.
  • Sodium: adults reduce intake to less than 2 grams/day (5g/day of salt), with this adjusted downward for children based on their energy requirements relative to adults.

Given all this, in setting regulations, WHO recommends that food profiling:

  • Be aligned with dietary guidance and diet-related noncommunicable disease reduction.
  • Be developed through transparent processes and informed by independent scientific expertise.
  • Focus on reducing exposure to nutrients and products of public health concern.
  • Be aligned with healthy and sustainable dietary patterns.
  • Be relevant and sufficiently simple to enable implementation, monitoring, and enforcement.

In summary, rather than focusing on a variety of definitions of “ultraprocessed” foods, WHO sees the model as providing a practical approach, grounded in established public health principles, for identifying foods whose consumption should be limited or moderated. When implemented through well-designed regulatory measures, it can provide a strong basis for dietary guidance to reduce diet-related obesity and non-communicable diseases and their public health burden.

While there is no requirement or expectation that either state or federal regulators will use the WHO guidance, one can at least hope that those developing definitions of ultraprocessed foods will pay attention to the main principles in the WHO document.  Any ultraprocessed labeling requirements should be focused on the key goal of having an impact on non-communicable diseases – which is what the WHO document is focused on.

Ready to elevate your brand protection?