Canada’s SFCA regulations are similar to the US FSMA rules in many ways, with both based on preventive, rather than reactive, practices. Additionally, both have many of the same provisions, however, the specifics of those do vary and can lead to product that is intended for import into the US being held at the border.
So, what are those differences? And what do Canadian food businesses need to do to aid in getting their foods across the border?
TAG sees four key areas as causing the most confusion – and potential import impact: traceability, food defence, facility registration, and the preventive controls/food safety plan.
- Facility Registration
- SFCR requires licenses for domestic and imported/exported food businesses, renewed every two years.
- FSMA requires that all food facilities, domestic or foreign, that manufacture, process, pack, or hold food for consumption in the U.S. register with the FDA, renew every two years, and designate a U.S. Agent.
- Compliance. This is the simplest one for Canadian businesses to comply with, as you simply create a free account and input your facility information. It does however, require a U.S. agent with whom FDA can communicate in an emergency
- How TAG can help. Need a US agent? Our US-based team can help. We also can assist with the registration should you need it.
- Traceability
- SFCR requires that a food business be able to trace product/ingredients one step back to the supplier and one step forward to the immediate customer.
- FSMA also requires one forward/one back, but for foods on the Food Traceability List, the Traceability Rule (FSMA 204) requires the tracking of Critical Tracking Events (CTEs) and associated Key Data Elements (KDEs), assigning a Traceability Lot Code (TLC), and providing a sortable electronic spreadsheet to the FDA upon request under strict timelines.
- Compliance. While US traceability is complex, compliance is not due until July 2028, and it only applies to foods on the Traceability List. So there is time to determine if the rule applies to you and how to comply.
- How TAG can help. TAG has been helping food companies understand and work to comply with the Traceability Rule since its initial conception, and is a founder and manager of the Partnership for Food Traceability (PFT), which was developed to help the industry close the gaps of interoperability across the chain.
- Food Defence
- SFCR has no regulations related to food defence policy requirements, although the SFCA does include a provision prohibiting anyone from tampering with a food commodity, label or packaging if the intent is to render it injurious to human health or cause fear of the same (Section 7)
- FSMA requires a written Food Defense Plan to guard against intentional adulteration.
- Compliance. Although it is not as strictly required in Canada as in the US, many Canadian companies do have food defence policies in place (e.g., locked doors, security gates, required sign ins, etc.). So compliance may be simply filling in the gaps of what FSMA requires.
- How TAG can help. TAG can help you develop a Food Defense Plan, or review your current policies against the FSMA requirements to determine the gaps and what is needed to close them.
- Preventive Controls Plan/Food Safety Plan
- SFCR requires a written Preventive Controls Plan (PCP) that covers hazards, sanitation, pest control, recall procedures, and allergen controls. The PCP also includes rules for packaging, labelling, grades, standards of identity, and humane treatment of food animals.
- FSMA requires a written Food Safety Plan (FSP) that is written and overseen by a Controls Qualified Individual (PCQI) who has completed FDA-recognized training. It focuses on food safety hazards, requiring written hazard analyses and scientific validation for biological, chemical, physical, radiological and economically motivated adulteration hazards.
- Compliance. This may be the most complex of the four, particularly in integrating provisions to ensure the plan fulfills both the SFCR and FSMA requirements. Additionally, Canadian companies who export to the US must have a trained PCQI who fully understands the FSMA regulation and writes/manages the FSP.
- How TAG can help. TAG can provide a review of your current PCP and its implementation, then work with you to adapt or add to it to fulfill FSMA FSP requirements as well. We can provide a remote paper audit, or visit your facility for a complete implementation review as well. TAG also offers PCQI training and has developed a class specifically focused toward Canadian facilities. The course is currently scheduled for February 8-10, 2027 and registration is currently open. For future course options, keep your eye on the TAG event page.
While the above are the four areas we see as having the most critical variances between the SFCR and FSMA, there are numerous other differences that can come into play when your shipment arrives at the US border. In addition to reviewing the above, TAG can also conduct a complete review of your preventive controls, supplier control programs, allergen programs, etc., to ensure they will meet the FDA’s requirements as well as CFIA’s.
In summary, the four key areas causing the most confusion and export impacts for Canadian food products into the United States are traceability, food defence, facility registration, and the preventive controls/food safety plan. Simply complying with SFCR only could lead to issues getting your product across the border. Ensure you know what FSMA requires, as well as CFIA so your product is not hung up at the border.